Good and Fun Debate Topics for Middle Schoolers

Good and Fun Debate Topics for Middle Schoolers

4310 Views15 Mins Read
TL;DR

35 good and fun debate topics for middle schoolers (grades 6 to 8): silly warm-ups, imagination, school life, screens and sports, animals and environment, and everyday values, each with an argument for both sides, the best grade, and a 20-minute classroom debate plan.

Good and Fun Debate Topics for Middle Schoolers: The Short Answer

Below are 35 debate topics for middle school students in grades 6 to 8, from silly warm-ups to questions about school, screens, animals and everyday choices. Every topic comes from a live VersyTalks debate, so students can read real arguments before they prepare. Each one has a short note on why it works, an argument for each side and the grade it suits best.

Start with the fun topics to teach structure and listening, then move to the school and values topics once students can give a reason and answer one. For a lesson plan, see "How to Run a 20-Minute Classroom Debate" below.

Fun and Silly Debate Topics (Warm-Ups)

1. Is cereal a soup?

A perfect first debate: students must define words before they can argue. See the live debate

One side: Cereal is a liquid with solid pieces in a bowl, eaten with a spoon. That is a soup.

Other side: Soups are savoury and usually cooked. Calling cereal a soup ignores what people actually mean.

Works best for: Grade 6

2. Is it better to read the book or watch the movie?

Everyone has evidence from their own life. See the live debate

One side: Books include details, thoughts and scenes that movies cut, and they let you imagine.

Other side: Movies bring stories to life with music and acting, and they reach people who do not read much.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

3. Sweet candy or sour candy?

A low-stakes topic for practising "because" and examples. See the live debate

One side: Sweet candy is the classic treat and pleases more people.

Other side: Sour candy is more exciting and lasts longer because you eat it slowly.

Works best for: Grade 6

4. Is money better than candy on Halloween?

Fun, but it opens real questions about value and tradition. See the live debate

One side: Money lasts, you can choose what to buy, and it is healthier.

Other side: Candy is the point of Halloween. Giving money takes the fun and tradition away.

Works best for: Grades 6 and 7

5. Is trick-or-treating for all ages?

Students argue about fairness and tradition. See the live debate

One side: Halloween is for everyone, and teenagers trick-or-treating is better than getting into trouble.

Other side: Trick-or-treating is meant for young children, and older kids can host parties or hand out candy instead.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

6. Haunted house or corn maze?

Great for comparing two options with clear criteria. See the live debate

One side: A haunted house gives the biggest thrill and makes a great story afterwards.

Other side: A corn maze is fun for everyone, including people who scare easily, and lets groups work together.

Works best for: Grade 6

7. Are artificial Christmas trees better than real ones?

A seasonal topic with surprising environmental arguments. See the live debate

One side: Artificial trees last for years, make no mess and save money over time.

Other side: Real trees are renewable, can be recycled and support local farms.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

8. Is Santa Claus a good role model for children?

Light topic, real reasoning about kindness and honesty. See the live debate

One side: Santa stands for generosity and kindness, and the story brings families together.

Other side: The story asks parents to lie, and it rewards children with presents for behaving.

Works best for: Grades 6 and 7

Imagination Debate Topics

9. If time travel were possible, should changing the past be legal?

Students must think through consequences step by step. See the live debate

One side: People could prevent disasters and fix terrible mistakes.

Other side: Changing one event could create worse problems no one can predict.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

10. Would the world be better if animals could talk?

A fun question that leads to real thinking about how we treat animals. See the live debate

One side: We would understand animals’ needs and treat them better.

Other side: Animals might tell us things we do not want to hear, and it could cause new conflicts.

Works best for: Grade 6

11. Should superheroes kill their villains?

Students use stories they love to argue about justice. See the live debate

One side: Villains keep escaping and hurting people. Stopping them for good protects the city.

Other side: Heroes are heroes because they do not kill. Killing would make them no better than villains.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

12. Should everyone take a lie detector test once a year?

Gets students thinking about honesty and privacy. See the live debate

One side: People would be more honest, and crimes would be easier to solve.

Other side: It would invade privacy, and lie detectors are not always accurate.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

13. Should dreams be recorded and shared like films?

Imaginative, with real questions about privacy. See the live debate

One side: It would be amazing entertainment and could help doctors study sleep.

Other side: Dreams are private, and some are scary or embarrassing.

Works best for: Grade 6

14. Should we build human colonies on the Moon?

Introduces cost and benefit thinking. See the live debate

One side: The Moon could be a base for exploring space and a backup home for humanity.

Other side: It would cost huge amounts of money that could help people on Earth.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

15. Should humans try to communicate with aliens?

A big question that is easy to start. See the live debate

One side: Contact could teach us new science and show we are not alone.

Other side: We do not know who might answer. It could be dangerous to reveal ourselves.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

School Life Debate Topics

16. Should schools ban homework?

Students have strong opinions and real experience. See the live debate

One side: Kids need time to rest, play and be with family, and homework causes stress.

Other side: Homework helps practise what you learn in class and builds good habits.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

17. Are participation trophies harming children’s resilience?

Good for weighing feelings against fairness. See the live debate

One side: Trophies for everyone make winning meaningless and do not prepare kids for losing.

Other side: Rewarding effort keeps kids playing and builds confidence.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

18. Should Halloween costumes be allowed in school?

Students argue about rules and fun. See the live debate

One side: Costumes make school fun and let students be creative.

Other side: Costumes can be distracting, expensive or offensive, and not everyone celebrates.

Works best for: Grade 6

19. Should children learn to care for an animal from a young age?

Students argue about responsibility. See the live debate

One side: Caring for a pet teaches responsibility, patience and kindness.

Other side: A pet is a big responsibility, and young children may not look after it properly.

Works best for: Grade 6

Screens, Games and Sports Debate Topics

20. Can video games be a legitimate career?

Connects to esports, streaming and careers students know. See the live debate

One side: Esports players, streamers and game designers earn real money in a growing industry.

Other side: Very few gamers succeed, and the career is short and uncertain.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

21. Do violent video games cause real-life violence?

Introduces the idea of evidence and correlation. See the live debate

One side: Playing violent games for hours may make players less sensitive to violence.

Other side: Millions of people play violent games without becoming violent. Other factors matter more.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

22. Should American football be banned?

Health versus tradition and choice. See the live debate

One side: Repeated hits can cause serious brain injuries, especially in young players.

Other side: Players choose the risk, rules can improve safety, and the sport builds teamwork.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

23. Are professional athletes’ salaries justified?

Introduces markets and fairness. See the live debate

One side: Athletes earn what fans and sponsors are willing to pay, and careers are short.

Other side: Teachers and nurses do more important work for far less money.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

Animals and Environment Debate Topics

24. Should domestic cats be allowed outside without supervision?

Students weigh animal freedom against safety and wildlife. See the live debate

One side: Cats are happier and healthier when they can explore.

Other side: Outdoor cats face traffic and predators, and they hunt birds.

Works best for: Grade 6

25. Should kittens always be adopted in pairs?

A gentle topic about animal needs. See the live debate

One side: Kittens learn from each other and are less lonely and destructive in pairs.

Other side: Not every family can afford two cats, and some cats prefer to be alone.

Works best for: Grade 6

26. Should parrots be kept as pets?

Introduces animal welfare. See the live debate

One side: Parrots can live happily with caring owners who give them space and attention.

Other side: Parrots are wild, social birds that live for decades and suffer in cages.

Works best for: Grades 6 and 7

27. Does the world need to reduce chocolate consumption?

A treat topic that leads to farming and environment. See the live debate

One side: Cocoa farming can harm forests and workers, and eating less is healthier.

Other side: Chocolate supports farmers’ incomes, and better farming is the answer, not eating less.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

28. Should single-use plastics be banned?

An environment topic every student can see around them. See the live debate

One side: Plastic pollutes oceans and harms animals, and alternatives exist.

Other side: Some plastics keep food safe and help people with disabilities, and bans can cost families more.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

Values and Everyday Choices Debate Topics

29. Is money the key to happiness?

A classic that lets students use examples from life. See the live debate

One side: Money pays for safety, health and freedom, which make people happier.

Other side: Friends, family and purpose matter more, and many rich people are unhappy.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

30. Are experiences more valuable than possessions?

Students compare memories and things. See the live debate

One side: Memories from trips and activities last longer than the excitement of new things.

Other side: Some possessions, like a bike or a book, create experiences and last for years.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

31. Should respect be earned or given by default?

Great for discussing fairness and kindness. See the live debate

One side: Respect means more when people earn it through their actions.

Other side: Everyone deserves basic respect, and treating people well helps them act well.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

32. Is it better to live in a big city or in the countryside?

Students compare criteria such as fun, safety and nature. See the live debate

One side: Cities have more schools, jobs, activities and people to meet.

Other side: The countryside is calmer, safer and closer to nature.

Works best for: Grades 6 to 8

33. Should the world have one universal language?

Opens questions about culture and communication. See the live debate

One side: A shared language would make travel, trade and friendship easier.

Other side: Languages carry culture and history, and losing them would make the world poorer.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

34. Should vacations be planned or spontaneous?

Easy to start, good for comparing options. See the live debate

One side: Planning avoids problems and makes sure you see what you want.

Other side: Spontaneous trips are more exciting and lead to surprises.

Works best for: Grade 6

35. Is Halloween still a true celebration or just commercial?

Students think about traditions and marketing. See the live debate

One side: Families still gather, dress up and celebrate together.

Other side: Stores push costumes and candy, and the holiday is mostly about buying things.

Works best for: Grades 7 and 8

How to Run a 20-Minute Classroom Debate

  1. Pick one topic and two teams (2 minutes). Use a fun topic for the first debate. Assign sides so students practise arguing a view that is not their own.
  2. Prepare (5 minutes). Each team writes two reasons, each with an example, and guesses one argument the other side will make.
  3. Opening speeches (4 minutes). One speaker per team gives a two-minute speech: claim, reason, example.
  4. Rebuttal (4 minutes). One speaker per team answers the other side: "They said..., but...".
  5. Closing and vote (5 minutes). Each team sums up in one minute. The class votes on which team argued better, not which side they agree with.

To keep it respectful, set one rule before you start: argue against ideas, never against people. For printable resources, see the classroom debate instructions.

Practise on VersyTalks

Students can read real arguments on every linked debate and post their own with a free account. When they are ready to speak, they can practise in debate drills, or debate another student in a Practice Room by recording their speech in turns. For more topics, see 100 debate topics and education debate topics.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a good debate topic for middle school?

A good middle school topic is easy to understand, connects to students’ lives and has reasonable arguments on both sides, such as "Should schools ban homework?" or "Can video games be a legitimate career?"

What are fun debate topics for middle schoolers?

Silly topics like "Is cereal a soup?", "Sweet or sour candy?" or "Should superheroes kill their villains?" work well. They teach structure and listening without the pressure of serious issues.

Should middle schoolers debate controversial topics?

It depends on the class. Start with fun and school topics, set clear rules for respect, and introduce serious topics once students can argue both sides calmly.

How long should a middle school debate be?

Twenty minutes is enough for a full classroom debate: preparation, opening speeches, rebuttals and a vote.

Related Posts

Modern & Provoking Gender Debate Topics

Nov 22, 2026

Modern & Provoking Gender Debate Topics

Gender Debate Topics: The Short Answer Below are 29 gender debate topics in five groups: gender identity and inclusion, work and...

1873 Views12 Mins Read