Rebuttal Mode

How it works:

Expand the argument to see its claim, evidence, and reasoning. Write your strongest rebuttal—up to 800 characters.

Rebuttals are key in debate!

Rebuttals sharpen your logic, train your critical and analytical skills, reveal weak points in arguments, and train real debate skill.

Is it ethical for a parent to post children’s content/sharenting on social media?

Claim

Sharenting constructs family and parenthood and it's unethical where it publicly shares intimate moments and everyday caregiving that exposes children to digital risks.

Context

Sharenting has become a practice among parents that often overlooks the need for privacy and intimacy, especially for young children already exposed to digital footprints.

Reason 1

While this practice is often viewed as sentimental for parents as they post milestones of their children, it becomes risky for children when they do not have the agency of consent. Such content often foster relatability and connection with audiences by displaying vulnerability (e.g children crying, parent's discipline), comfort, and assurance between parent and child in the videos.

Evidence

Sharenting enacts family life before a wider audience. This transforms caregiving, parental responsibilities, and emotional interaction into shared moments in digital spaces like Tiktok. However, it becomes risky when it's being used for profit, and when the child has no agency on its digital identity.

Conclusion

When parents are not aware of the risks, posting children's content on social media is not just merely about sentimentality or family life, but rather the risks in digital spaces.

Versy

Join VersyTalks to participate

Learn More
How it works:

Expand the argument to see its claim, evidence, and reasoning. Write your strongest rebuttal—up to 800 characters.

Rebuttals are key in debate!

Rebuttals sharpen your logic, train your critical and analytical skills, reveal weak points in arguments, and train real debate skill.

Rebuttals